For a woman researching non-hormonal menopause supplements, these two brands come up over and over. Bonafide is the science-forward, clinician-marketed line built specifically for menopausal symptoms, with Relizen as the headline product. HUM Nutrition is the broader beauty-from-within wellness brand whose menopause-relevant formulas (like Fan Club for hot flashes and Big Chill for mood support) sit alongside dozens of other targeted supplements.
The short answer: Bonafide wins for vasomotor symptoms (hot flashes and night sweats). HUM wins for the surrounding stuff (mood, skin, sleep adjacency, gut health). Many women run both, on different symptoms, at the same time.
The Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Bonafide | HUM Nutrition |
|---|---|---|
| Menopause-specific formulas | Yes (Relizen, Ristela, Serenol) | Some (Fan Club, Big Chill) |
| Hot flash / night sweat support | Strongest, Relizen has clinical data | Lighter, Fan Club is gentler |
| Mood and emotional support | Serenol, decent | Big Chill, more comprehensive |
| Libido support | Ristela, the only direct option | None specifically |
| Skin / hair / nails | Limited | Hair Sweet Hair, Glow Sweet Glow |
| Gut and digestion | None specifically | Gut Instinct, Wing Man, Flatter Me |
| Monthly cost (one product) | $50 (Relizen) | $26 to $40 (most products) |
| Subscription discount | Up to 25% off | 15% off |
Where Bonafide Wins
Vasomotor Symptoms (Hot Flashes and Night Sweats)
Relizen is the flagship product, and it has actual published clinical data behind it. The active is a Swedish flower pollen extract that has been studied for menopausal vasomotor symptoms in randomized trials. Many women report a noticeable reduction in hot flash frequency within 60 to 90 days. My friend, age 53, ran Relizen for 12 weeks and reported her hot flashes dropped from 8-10 a day to 2-3 a day. That's the most consistent symptom shift I've seen in any non-hormonal supplement.
Libido
This is the underrated Bonafide product. Ristela is built around L-arginine, French maritime pine bark extract, L-citrulline, and rose hips, with published studies on female sexual function and arousal in postmenopausal women. There is genuinely no HUM equivalent. If libido is the symptom you'd quietly Google at 2 a.m., Ristela is the one to look at.
Clinical Sourcing
Bonafide products tend to be sold through clinician offices and recommended by menopause specialists. The line is sharper, more evidence-based, and less wellness-coded than HUM's catalog. If you're a woman who responds better to "my OBGYN's office sells this" than "the wellness magazine recommended it," Bonafide reads as more credible.
Bonafide is the supplement line you'd find on a menopause specialist's shelf. HUM is the line you'd find on a thoughtful 30-something's bathroom counter, with formulas that happen to overlap into menopause.
Where HUM Wins
Mood and Emotional Support
HUM's Big Chill (containing rhodiola, ashwagandha, and chamomile) is broader, gentler, and pairs well with the kind of low-grade mood drift many women report in perimenopause. Bonafide's Serenol exists in this space too, but most women I know prefer Big Chill's daily-feel.
The Total Wellness Stack
HUM's catalog goes wider than Bonafide's. If you also want to address skin (Glow Sweet Glow, Collagen Pop), hair thinning (Hair Sweet Hair), gut (Flatter Me, Gut Instinct), or hangover-grade liver support (Wing Man), you can build a coherent stack inside one brand. Bonafide does not try to be that comprehensive.
Cost and Accessibility
Most HUM products run $26 to $40 a month. Most Bonafide products run $40 to $60. If you're trying multiple things at once, the math adds up faster with Bonafide.
Who Should Buy Bonafide
Choose Bonafide if:
Your top complaint is hot flashes, night sweats, or libido changes; you want clinical data behind the supplement you're swallowing; you'd rather pay more for a sharper, narrower formula; or your menopause specialist or OBGYN already mentioned Relizen or Ristela by name.
Who Should Buy HUM
Choose HUM if:
You're navigating a wider mix of symptoms (mood, skin, hair, gut, sleep adjacency), you want one brand's catalog to handle the whole stack, you prefer a wellness-coded experience, or your symptoms are gentler and you want to start with something less clinical.
The Bottom Line
If hot flashes are wrecking your life or your libido has dropped off a cliff, Bonafide is the smarter first stop. The clinical data is the most robust in the non-hormonal supplement space, and the per-symptom focus pays off. If you're in the messier "everything feels a little off" territory of perimenopause, HUM is the easier on-ramp, and the catalog lets you adjust as your symptoms shift.
Many women I know run both, on different symptoms, and that combination is genuinely the best of both worlds.
Start where your symptoms are loudest
Bonafide subscribers get up to 25% off. HUM's bundle pricing makes a 2-3 product stack roughly the price of one Bonafide formula. Run a 90-day test on whichever brand fits your top symptom and decide from there.
See Bonafide